Loading...
Loading...
Category: Listing Optimization
By: Megan O'Connor
Reply by Michael Thompson:
Average review rate is about 50-60%. Top hosts get 70-80%. Here's what got me there: Biggest single thing: leave YOUR review first, and do it fast. When you review the guest, they get a notification and feel compelled to reciprocate. When I review within 2 hours of checkout, 72% of guests review me back. When I wait 24+ hours, it drops to 48%. Huge difference. In my checkout message I mention reviews but frame it around THEM: "We've left you a 5-star review! If you get a chance, we'd love to hear about your stay — your feedback helps other travelers find our place." Telling them you already reviewed them triggers the reciprocity instinct, and framing it as helping others feels less self-serving than "please review us." Mid-stay check-ins help too, but not directly. When I message "everything going well?" on day 2, it catches problems before they become bad reviews AND makes the guest feel cared for. Both lead to better and more frequent reviews. The most underrated strategy: exceed expectations in ONE memorable way. A generic-but-fine stay doesn't inspire anyone to write a review. But a handwritten welcome note, a perfect restaurant recommendation, or a little birthday surprise? That creates the "I need to tell people about this" feeling. Finally, I send one follow-up 5 days after checkout for guests who haven't reviewed yet. Something simple: "Hope you made it home safely! If you haven't had a chance yet, we'd love a review of your stay. Here's the link." Only 30% of guests who intend to review actually do it in the first few days — this catches the forgetful ones. Do NOT ask specifically for 5 stars (Airbnb policy violation), don't offer incentives, and don't send more than one reminder. One gentle nudge is fine, two is pushy. After all this, my review rate went from 52% to 78%. For generating your review responses: https://strspecialist.com/tools/review-response-generator.
Reply by Daniel Kowalski:
One more tactic: **the physical review card.** I leave a small tent card on the nightstand (like a hotel comment card): Front: "Enjoyed your stay? ⭐" Back: QR code linking directly to the Airbnb review page, with text "Scan to share your experience. It takes 30 seconds and helps future travelers!" The physical card catches guests at the right moment — in bed before sleep, or while packing. It's less intrusive than a message because they discover it naturally. I tested this across 6 properties for 3 months: - Properties WITH card: 74% review rate - Properties WITHOUT card: 57% review rate The QR code is key. Sending guests to a URL requires typing. A QR code takes 2 seconds to scan on their phone. Remove every friction point and review rates go up.