Loading...
Loading...
Category: Legal & Regulations
By: Omar Hassan
Reply by Brittany Simmons:
Former NYC host here — I gave up and moved my investing to the Catskills, but I can tell you exactly what the current rules are. Local Law 18 basically killed traditional Airbnb in NYC. The requirements are brutal: you must register with the Office of Special Enforcement, you must be PHYSICALLY PRESENT during the guest's entire stay, max 2 guests, and no locks on bedroom doors. So basically you can rent a room in your apartment while you're home. That's it. Renting your whole apartment while you travel? Illegal. Investment property listed full-time? Illegal. Anything that looks like a hotel operation? Very illegal. The registration backlog is insane — 3-6 months to process, and roughly 70% of applications get rejected. The city actively monitors Airbnb listings and fines start at $1,000 and go up fast. Realistically if you own property in NYC your options are: - Mid-term 30+ day rentals (not subject to STR rules) through Furnished Finder or Airbnb monthly - Traditional long-term rental - Corporate housing A lot of former NYC hosts I know have pivoted across the river to Jersey City or Hoboken. Still close to Manhattan via PATH train but way more manageable regulations. Not perfect — Jersey City has a 60-day annual cap — but at least it's doable. If you're looking to invest, stick to tourist destination markets where STR is actually welcome. NYC hasn't been worth the headache since 2023. For market-by-market regulation updates, check https://strspecialist.com/blog.
Reply by Megan O'Connor:
Adding some NYC nuances most people miss: **Borough differences:** While the law applies citywide, enforcement intensity varies: - Manhattan: highest enforcement, they actively scrape listings - Brooklyn: high enforcement - Queens/Bronx/Staten Island: lower enforcement but still risky **The "host present" loophole:** Some hosts interpret "present" creatively — like having a room they nominally "live in" while renting the rest. OSE inspectors have become wise to this and will check for personal belongings, utility usage patterns, and mail delivery. **New Jersey alternative:** Many former NYC STR investors have pivoted to: - Jersey City (60-day annual cap, permit required, but still viable) - Hoboken (limited STR allowed) - Newark (less regulation but lower demand) - These NJ cities are 15-30 min from Manhattan. Tourists still get the "NYC experience" via PATH train **Long-term trend:** NYC's strict approach is being studied by other cities. Chicago, Boston, and DC have implemented similarly restrictive frameworks. The days of "list anything anywhere on Airbnb" are over in major metros. Tourist destinations remain the safest bet for STR investment.