Head-to-head comparison · Updated July 2026
Turno vs TIDY
Two of the best-reviewed turnover platforms in short-term rental — nearly tied in our testing, with genuinely different approaches to scheduling and pricing.
The biggest cleaner marketplace — 55,000+ pros plus your own team
AI-driven turnover automation with usage-based pricing that scales to zero
The quick verdict
Both score almost identically — Turno 89/100, TIDY 88/100 — so the decision comes down to your cleaner situation and pricing preference. Turno wins if you want access to its 55,000+ cleaner marketplace and a free tier when you exclusively use marketplace pros. TIDY wins if you already have your own cleaning team and want AI-driven scheduling with usage-based pricing (3% per job, free for inactive properties) rather than a flat per-property fee.
…you want the largest marketplace of vetted cleaners to draw from, a genuinely free tier if you only use marketplace pros, and the most battle-tested turnover platform in STR.
…you want AI handling scheduling and restocking decisions, flexible usage-based pricing that costs nothing on inactive properties, and deep PMS-native automation.
Turno vs TIDY at a glance
Scores come from our hands-on testing rubric — how we test STR software. Vendors can’t pay for placement.
| Our score | 89/100 | 88/100 |
| Best for | Hosts who want access to a cleaner marketplace | Hosts with their own team wanting AI-driven automation |
| Free tier | Free if using only Turno Marketplace cleaners | Free for inactive properties on Flex plan |
| Paid pricing | $8–10/property/month (own cleaners) | 3% per job (Flex) or $10/unit/month annual (Standard) |
| Cleaner marketplace | 55,000+ vetted pros worldwide | Vendor marketplace, more limited/US-focused |
| Automation | Auto-schedule from PMS/OTA bookings, primary/backup cleaners | AI automates scheduling, inspections, restocking decisions |
| Payments | Built-in auto-payments via Stripe | No native payments — via integrations |
| PMS integrations | Broad direct PMS/OTA sync | Host Tools, Beds24, Housecall Pro, ChargeAutomation (iCal/Zapier for others) |
| Mobile app | Host and cleaner apps with photo checklists | GPS-enabled mobile app with real-time updates |
| Full review | Turno review → | TIDY review → |
Score battle: rubric results side by side
Sub-scores from the same testing rubric we apply to every tool in the cleaning & operations software directory.
The full breakdown
5 dimensions that actually decide which tool fits, based on running both on real listings.
01Pricing models
It’s a tieBoth offer genuine free tiers with different conditions — model your actual usage before choosing.
Turno is free if you exclusively use cleaners from its marketplace — the platform earns from cleaner-side fees instead. If you run your own cleaning team, Host Subscription runs $8–10 per property per month (annual discounts available), covering scheduling, checklists and auto-payments for your own "non-Turno teammates."
TIDY’s Flex plan charges 3% of each job’s cost with no fee at all on inactive properties — genuinely usage-based, which suits seasonal or lower-occupancy hosts. Standard is a flat $10/unit/month (annual) or $20 monthly for hosts who’d rather have predictable billing. Both scored 9/10 on value; run your numbers against your actual turnover volume, since the 3%-of-job-cost model can edge out a flat per-property fee at low volume and reverse at high volume.
- Free with marketplace cleaners only
- $8–10/property/mo for own team
- Built-in Stripe payments
- Flex: 3% per job, free if inactive
- Standard: $10/unit/mo annual
- No native payment processing
02Cleaner marketplace & sourcing
Winner: TurnoTurno’s 55,000+ cleaner network is the largest in short-term rental, by a wide margin.
Turno’s marketplace is its defining feature: 55,000+ vetted cleaning professionals across major markets worldwide, bookable directly through the platform when you need coverage — new market, sick cleaner, sudden portfolio growth. Its own data suggests improving cleanliness scores from 4.6 to 4.8 through the automation and accountability tools can lift bookings by roughly 20%.
TIDY also runs a vendor marketplace for cleaners and maintenance pros, but it’s smaller and more US-focused, with quality depending on local pro availability. If sourcing reliable cleaners on demand is your actual problem (not just scheduling the ones you already have), Turno’s network size is the deciding factor.
03Scheduling & AI automation
Winner: TIDYTIDY leans further into AI decision-making; Turno automates the mechanics well without claiming to be AI-first.
TIDY markets itself as AI-powered: it automates turnover scheduling, generates inspection tasks, and can trigger restocking based on PMS data patterns, aiming to reduce the host’s day-to-day decision load. In our testing, its automation felt genuinely predictive rather than just rule-based.
Turno automates the core loop reliably — reservations import from your PMS/OTA and cleans get scheduled with primary and backup cleaner assignments — but it’s automation-by-rules rather than AI-driven inference. Both scored well (Turno 10/10 automation, TIDY 9/10), and the practical difference is subtle: TIDY adapts more; Turno is more predictable and easier to reason about when something needs manual override.
04PMS integrations & payments
Winner: TurnoTurno syncs more PMS platforms directly and includes built-in payments; TIDY leans on Zapier for some.
Turno connects broadly across major PMS and OTA platforms for reservation sync, and its built-in Stripe payments mean cleaner payouts happen automatically inside the platform — no separate payment step.
TIDY integrates directly with Host Tools, Beds24, Housecall Pro and ChargeAutomation, and covers additional platforms via iCal or Zapier — workable, but an extra layer of setup for PMS platforms outside its direct list. TIDY also has no native payment processing, relying on integrations for that piece. If a single connected platform with payments built in matters to you, Turno is more complete out of the box.
05Checklists, inspections & quality control
It’s a tieBoth use photo-verified checklists and mobile apps well — pick based on marketplace vs. AI preference above.
Turno’s photo-guided checklists, inventory tracking and cleaner performance tools give hosts a clear before/after record and a way to hold cleaners accountable, accessible through dedicated host and cleaner apps.
TIDY’s mobile app for pros includes GPS check-in, photo documentation and real-time status updates, with AI-generated inspection tasks layered on top. Quality control is a wash between them — both give you the photo evidence and structure that separates a real STR cleaning platform from a group text with your cleaner.
Current pricing, plan by plan
Pulled from our reviews and re-checked against vendor pricing pages. Always confirm on the vendor site before committing.
Full platform (auto-scheduling, auto-payments, calendar sync, checklists, host/cleaner apps, support) when you exclusively use Turno Marketplace cleaners.
Good for new or small hosts who rely on marketplace pros.
All features plus ability to manage your own non‑Turno teammates (cleaners, maintenance, inspectors) with scheduling and payments.
Best for portfolios that mainly use their own cleaners.
Pay 3% per job; free inactive properties; full features.
For 10+ jobs/year.
Flat rate, full operations software.
STR focus.
Long‑term rental variant.
LTR specific.
Which one should you choose?
Choose Turno if…
- You want access to a large marketplace of vetted cleaners, not just tools for your existing team
- You want built-in cleaner payments (Stripe) without a separate payment step
- A flat per-property fee is easier for you to budget than usage-based billing
- You need broad direct PMS/OTA integration without relying on Zapier
- You want the platform with the largest track record and cleaner base in STR
Choose TIDY if…
- You already have your own reliable cleaning team and want smarter scheduling around them
- Usage-based pricing (3% per job, free when inactive) fits your seasonal occupancy pattern
- You want AI handling more of the day-to-day scheduling and restocking decisions
- Your PMS is Host Tools, Beds24, Housecall Pro or ChargeAutomation
- You’re comfortable managing cleaner payments through a separate integration
The bottom line
A one-point gap (89 vs 88) reflects two platforms that have both matured into genuinely reliable turnover management — you won’t make a bad choice here. Turno’s marketplace scale is unmatched if sourcing cleaners is part of your problem; its free tier for marketplace-only hosts is one of the best deals in STR software.
TIDY earns its place by leaning into AI and flexible usage-based pricing, which suits hosts who already have reliable cleaners and want the software to get smarter around them rather than to find them new people. If you’re unsure, Turno’s free marketplace-only tier costs nothing to try first.
Turno vs TIDY: FAQ
Not sold on either? Also consider
Broader operations suite (Properly’s parent company) for larger teams.
Read reviewInternational cleaning marketplace with strong European coverage.
Read reviewHousekeeping-specific scheduling for larger management companies.
Read reviewCompare every cleaning & operations software option we’ve tested — scores, pricing and best-for in one table.
Best Cleaning & Operations SoftwareWe test every tool hands-on and vendors cannot pay for rankings or scores. Some links are affiliate links — if you buy through them we may earn a commission at no cost to you, which funds independent testing. See our disclosure.